THE BATTLE OF THE CLASSES
First
Class
Business
Class
Economy
Class
ECONOMY CLASS
A Terrific Bargain or a Long and Slow
Torture?
For many people, coach
seats, especially heavily discounted ones, means the
ability to travel, and that's a real plus. For others
though, Economy Class is just that: an economic way to
get from one place to another, but it is by no means a
luxury. In fact, most executives dread flying in the
back of the plane, but some companies have less of a
choice these days. Although the travel industry has
seen a bit of a rebound post-Sept. 11, 2001, many
companies are feeling the pinch and are under pressure
to find the lowest fares possible. In general, many
airlines and travel agents admit that most recent
bookings are due to severely slashed prices. We are
currently seeing some of the lowest rates in a long
time, especially in the back of the plane, and this is
by no means limited to the newer "no frills" airlines.
Economy Class is an economic reality at the
moment.
Many business
travelers are now required to avoid full-fare Business
Class tickets, since they can take advantage of
rock-bottom prices aimed at leisure travelers, and
most ticket prices are so low in cost that passengers
are definitely, "getting what they pay for". In other
words, Economy Class has become more "economic" than
ever before. Many domestic carriers have eliminated
meal and entertainment services on short-haul flights.
Which is great for a family of five, to visit grandma,
but for those who fly frequently and are accustomed to
flying business class or better, it's a bitter pill to
swallow. There is some good news, because of a
"temporary economic downturn", airlines are retiring
older planes, and many will replace them with new ones
once capacity returns to normal. Although, the FAA's
predicted full-capacity rebound is not for another two
years, when this does happen, passengers will be
boarding much more spacious fleets.
In fact, in the effort
to lure more business travelers with low fares and
keep them happy many airlines are continuing with
previous plans to upgrade coach services, particularly
international carriers, who have not been as affected
as those in the U.S.. Cathay Pacific is rolling out
electrical outlets and data ports, and All Nippon
Airways inaugurated Premium Economy on its Tokyo to
London. ANA's Premium Economy offers luxuries such as
slippers, digital on-demand audio and video channels
and a separate check-in area. Amazingly, the seats in
Premium Economy cost no more than regular economy;
they are available to full-fare coach passengers on a
first-come, first-serve basis.
There's also the
options that servers such as JetBlue and Midwest
Express offer travelers, amenities like individual
televisions with JetBlue and fresh-baked cookies with
Midwest. Seats on these planes are marginally more
spacious than those belonging to the major airlines
and that's no small comfort, even if you'd rather be
flying First Class.
The trend towards
upgrading economy to a roomier coach is catching on.
Although it's true that not all seats are created
equal, as anyone who has flown First Class will attest
to, there is now some comfort available for those who
fly coach. As airlines compete for passengers in a
slowing economy, they are focusing more closely on the
one component of an airplane outside the cargo hold
that makes money: the Seat.
British Airways,
Midwest Express, Garuda, Virgin Atlantic, Aloha and
Air France are among the airlines seeking to give more
space and better service to passengers paying full
economy fares. Still, airlines can squeeze in as many
passengers as they like, subject to the plane-maker's
specifications and an internationally agreed upon
minimum seat pitch of 28 inches. The pitch is the
distance between an attachment point on one seat and
the same point on the next seat, and it is definitely
not the equivalent of legroom. Pitch also does not
take into account the thickness of the seat back, the
magazine pouch, or the tray. Then you still have to
contend with the passenger in front of you, who
insists on reclining his seat into your lap. That's
why many airlines have introduced thin and hard seats
in Economy Class. This allows a bit more room for your
knees, but an awful alternative for the rest of your
body.
Some companies see the
low-margin passengers as a valuable profit, and the
trend is toward an improvement in economy. Airlines go
to all sorts of lengths to find out what their
passengers demand from seating. They typically carry
out investigations through focus groups and passenger
questionnaires, or have their staff members test drive
the seats. In addition to more comfort, passengers
will soon be expecting seats with built-in
entertainment systems and laptop ports throughout the
planes.
With hard economic
times forcing more business passengers to the back of
the plane, some airlines are being forced, in turn, to
focus attention on the quality of travel in coach. A
few are creating what is, in effect, a fourth class
for passengers paying full economy fare, offering more
space, better service and the ability to use personal
computers while in flight.
United Airlines
started the trend toward a U.S. premium Economy Class
in 1999 by offering several rows of more spacious
seating to its frequent fliers. American Airlines
responded by offering more room throughout the coach
section; the airline removed 7,200 seats from its
fleet of 700 aircraft. Recently, Scandinavian Airlines
System introduced its new Economy Class for long haul
flights in connection with the debut of its Airbus
A340 aircraft. Called "Economy Extra", the class
"between economy and business" offers more leg room
and wider seats than the airline's regular Economy
Class, plus power ports for laptop computers,
adjustable headrests and footrests. All Economy Class
seats on SAS's new planes have video screens in the
seat backs. As you can see, each airline is taking
steps to improve "the back of the bus", and hopefully
we will see more improvements in the near future.
Comfortable travel, plus the ability to work, all at
an acceptable price, is the trend to follow.