Bird Flu Risks for Air Travelers
By Dr. Todd Curtis,
The AirSafe.com Foundation
Avian Influenza, commonly referred to as Bird Flu, is
not a new disease. What is relatively new about it is
that the spread of the virus, primarily from migrating
birds, has increased risk of human exposure to the
virus that causes the disease. While cases of
transmission of the Bird Flu virus from birds to
humans have occurred since 1997, there have so far
been no reported cases of transmissions from human to
human. For the world's air travelers, this means that
the current risk of infection from being in an
airplane is essentially zero. However, this present
situation does not mean that there will be no danger
in the future. As events in recent years have shown,
it is possible for passengers to contract a fatal case
of the flu after an in-flight exposure. A mutation
that allows the Bird Flu virus to be easily
transmitted from human to human would certainly put
airline passengers at risk.
In December 2003, the
New England Journal of Medicine published a study that
concluded that in March of 2003, six passengers died
from SARS (Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome) after
having been exposed to an infected passenger. The
exposures occurred on two separate flights. Should the
Bird Flu virus change to the point that human to human
transmission is possible, then any passenger flying on
any aircraft may be at risk. Unlike viruses such as
HIV that require direct contact with the body fluids
of an infected person in order to pass on the virus,
flu viruses like Bird Flu can often be transmitted
through less intimate contact such as being in close
proximity to an infected person in an
airliner.
Even if Bird Flu were
to evolve into a virus that can be transmitted from
human to human, the risks that airline passengers
would fact would depend on several factors such as how
easily the virus can be transmitted, the amount of
time between exposure and the onset of symptoms, and
the likelihood that a person infected with this virus
would eventually die from the effects of the disease.
In a worst case scenario, the Bird Flu virus would
mutate into a form that allows human to human
transmission, a significant percentage of those who
are exposed become ill, and the number of exposures
reaches epidemic proportions before public health
authorities are unable to identify the seriousness of
the threat. So far, there is no evidence that such an
outbreak is either occurring or about to
occur.
The experience with
SARS provides perhaps the closest comparison to the
situation with Bird Flu. Then, as now, public health
authorities were concerned that SARS could spread
easily and cause a widespread outbreak. Then, as now,
the major media organizations were very keen on
reporting outbreaks and providing information on the
potential threat. The key difference with the current
situation with Bird Flu is that it is unclear whether
the virus will remain a potential major threat or an
actual major threat. At present, there are no reported
cases of human to human transmission and no large
outbreaks of the disease among humans.
In the case of SARS,
the disease was certainly fatal to some who exposed to
the virus, but the existence of these SARS outbreaks
did not lead to any unusual disruption in normal
activities such as air travel. If the present
situation with Bird Flu does not change in any
significant way, there would very likely be little or
no impact on the air transportation system. Should the
worse case scenario become a reality and if Bird Flu
were to become a worldwide epidemic, it is quite
unclear how air transportation may be affected. The
best advice that AirSafe.com could give to the average
air traveler would be to monitor the media reports
about Bird Flu and to be on the lookout for any
reports of human to human transmission. If that
happens, and if it looks like the disease is become
widespread, then travel in any mode of transportation
open to the public, including airline travel, would
increase your risk of getting infected.
Fortunately for the
traveling public, there is substantial information
about Bird Flu that can be easily accessed.
AirSafe.com has created a page at
http://www.airsafe.com/issues/medical/birdflu.htm that
has several convenient links to some of this
information. If you visit the AirSafe.com web site,
you should be able to find a link to this information
on the home page, or you can find it by using the
AirSafe.com search engine.
For additional
information please go to:
http://www.airsafe.com/issues/medical/birdflu.htm
There is also a
podcast based on this article at http://www.airsafe.com/podcasts/show9.mp3
Dr. Todd Curtis is president of the
AirSafe.com Foundation and creator of the web
site AirSafe.com.
Todd Curtis conducted research in several areas of
aviation risk assessment and accident prevention.
Author of the book Understanding Aviation Safety Data
as well as a number of articles on Web site planning
and airline safety. Licensed private pilot.